This debate has raged on for decades: Who is the best athlete at a particular school? The Press’ longtime high school sports reporter, Michael McGarry, attempts to answer that age-old debate. Today, McGarry breaks down the top athletes at Pleasantville High School. These lists are not perfect — let us know who we forgot or overlooked. Let him know at or on Twitter @ACPressMcGarry.

Recommended for you

Load comments